|
A NEW PARADIGM FOR HEALTH
by David Hilton, MD
Ecumenical Health Ministries
E-mail: dhilton@emory.edu
At the World Health Assembly in 1990 the Director General called for
"a new paradigm of health." I wrote to the Director General strongly
supporting that call, but respectfully suggesting that he could find that
paradigm buried in the files of his own office. For the World Health Organization
at its inception over 40 years ago adopted a prophetic paradigm that has
been for the most part ignored.
WHO defines health as "not merely the absence of disease but a
state of well being." But how many of the present WHO staff are working
on "absence of disease" and how many on "well being?"
It has been much easier to conceptualize and implement work directly attacking
well-defined diseases (the biomedical model), whether through prevention
or intervention, than to promote well being. The reason that this has not
been sufficiently effective, leading the DG to call for a new paradigm,
is that health is not primarily medical.
In spite of the impressive eradication of smallpox by sophisticated
and expensive technology, it is becoming increasingly obvious that most
of the world's health problems cannot be best addressed in this way. The
causes of disease in the world are more economic, social, and spiritual,
than biomedical.
JUSTICE AND HEALTH
It is widely acknowledged that the number one cause of disease in the
world is poverty. Providing immunizations, medicines, and even health education
by standard methods cannot significantly ameliorate illness due to poverty.
This as a justice issue to be raised in the centers of power--local, national,
regional, and global. To address the world's major cause of illness, those
promoting health must lead all nations to work together to change unjust
economic structures which create and perpetuate poverty. While primary
health care works toward a more just distribution of available resources
for health, both within and between nations, a top-down paternalism in
its implementation often inhibits the development of community resources
and achievement of self-reliance. The resulting dependency on outside resources
for the provision of health care services has ultimately served the rich
and powerful rather than the poor.
HEALTH AND PEACE
Armed conflict and other forms of political violence are another threat
to the health of millions in our time. State terrorism through "low
intensity conflict," torture, imprisonment and other forms of human
rights violations have made well-being an impossibility. The threat of
nuclear annihilation hangs over the entire globe, often suppressing hope.
No medications can remedy the personal and social illness arising out of
this world climate of militarism. If we are truly concerned with health,
we must address this major root cause.
HEALTH AND ENVIRONMENT
Another significant proportion of illness in the world is self-inflicted.
What we impose on ourselves individually and collectively--whether out
of ignorance, greed, or simply lack of self-control--causes physical, mental,
spiritual and ecological damage which is not best addressed by medical
technology. Lifestyles and values which grow out of individualism increasingly
cause disruption of social networks and life in community.
In industrialized countries, more than 80% of illness and death are
reported to be due to destructive lifestyles, and the problem is growing
rapidly as a result of "modernization" throughout the world.
Development of heart disease, hypertension, and diabetes has accompanied
industrial development in many countries with the introduction of new diets
and attitudes toward manual labor. In the name of "economic growth"
sophisticated methods are used to promote all kinds of over-consumption
in the face of mounting evidence that it is severely destructive to health.
Governments, while spending millions to prevent traffic in illicit drugs,
promote the most widely used and destructive of addicting drugs, alcohol
and nicotine, through duty free shops and trade agreements.
As nations large and small struggle for military and technological supremacy,
nuclear wastes proliferate to endanger the health of the whole planet.
Health professionals must be active in advocating and protecting the
integrity of creation, with concern both for the human body and for the
critical conditions which are necessary to sustain life.
HEALTH AND LIFE
All human beings are faced with the question of the meaning of life.
This spiritual dimension is most important to health. Medical science is
now demonstrating that beliefs and feelings are potent modulators of the
body's powerful, health-controlling immune system. We are discovering that
scientific medicine is dealing very superficially with illness, ignoring
root causes with the excuse that there is no "hard data."
Traditional societies have long had an approach to health which knows
disturbances in beliefs, feelings, and relationships to be root causes
of illness but we ignore that factor while concentrating on the pharmaceutical
analysis of herbal medicines. Much can be learned from a dialogue between
traditional healers and Western medical practitioners. IMPLEMENTING THE
NEW PARADIGM
Although WHO's charter says health is not simply the absence of disease
but a state of complete well being, all WHO programs around the world are
disease oriented. That is because well being is not a scientific concept
that can easily be addressed by medical science. But there is one organization
in the world whose focus is primarily well-being: the Church. Jesus said
"I have come that you might have life in all its fullness." That
is well being. In the Old Testament the Hebrew word shalowm appears many
times. We often translate it into the English word peace, but shalowm actually
means well-being.
So it is the function of the Church to be the real World Health Organization.
We must recognize this and redouble our efforts to address the issues outlined
above. The Bible is a book of justice and portrays God's option for the
poor and marginalized from cover to cover. Jesus said "Woe to you,
scribes and Pharisees, hypocrites! For you tithe mint, dill, and cummin,
and have neglected the weightier matters of the law: justice and mercy
and faith. It is these you ought to have practiced without neglecting the
others" (Matt 23:23). The role of the Church in health and healing
is an idea whose time has come, again. It is the function of the Church
to be the real World Health Organization.
It is the function of the Church
to be the real World Health Organization.
Editor's Note:
"Health Teaching and West Africa" and several
informative trip reports by David Hilton are also available at this website.
|